Mar 7, 2012 08:40
12 yrs ago
English term

Heroic versus Incremental Sanctioning

English to Russian Social Sciences Social Science, Sociology, Ethics, etc. social sunctions
Source: http://solomon.tinyurl.alexanderstreet.com/cgi-bin/asp/philo...

Examination of the ways in which norms are characteristically enforced makes it clear that a common mode of sanctioning can be characterized as incremental sanctioning. This is exemplified in unions by "putting in Coventry" scabs and others who seriously violate union norms; that is, other members refuse to speak to the transgressor (Lipset, Trow, and Coleman, 1956). It is also exemplified by the development of a "reputation," which is followed by avoidance or snubbing. In incremental sanctioning the cost incurred by each sanctioner is small, and the effect of each sanctioning is small as well, but the effects are additive, giving a large total effect.

Aesop's fable "The Mice in Council," however, is a reminder that it is not always possible to sanction incrementally. To bell the cat was not an activity that could be engaged in by additive increments. It required what I will call a heroic sanction, that is, a sanction whose total effect occurs through a single actor's action. In the examples of norms and sanctions given earlier in this chapter, the sanctions were imposed by single individuals.

Discussion

Serge Vazhnenko (asker) Mar 7, 2012:
Это как в медицине: heroic treatment - радикальное средство или метод лечения с повышенной опасностью для больного
VGayek Mar 7, 2012:
Ну тогда может быть:)
Serge Vazhnenko (asker) Mar 7, 2012:
В приведенном мной источнике упоминается басня Эзопа о мышах и коте. Повязать колокольчик коту - весьма радикальная санкция!
VGayek Mar 7, 2012:
не уверен, что "героические" являются именно радикальными, хотя исходя из их высокой затратности, м.б.
Serge Vazhnenko (asker) Mar 7, 2012:
Благодарю за полезную ссылку! А как Вам такой вариант: "Радикальные и инкрементальные санкции" ? Имеет он "право на жизнь"? :-)

Proposed translations

21 mins
Selected

санкции, применяемые "героями", и санкции с нарастающим эффектом

Первые санкции поэтапно применяются большим кругом лиц (т.е. их эффект постепенно нарастает), а вторые - применяются точечно, отдельными людьми, но являются более дорогостоящими. См. ссылку
Example sentence:

“Incremental sanctioning,” implies situations in which sanctions with relatively low costs are implemented and enforced by a large number of people.

“Heroic sanctioning,” by contrast, implies that sanctions with relatively high costs are implemented and enforced by a small number of “heroic” sanctioners (see Table I).

Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Еще раз спасибо за полезную ссылку."
6 hrs

героические меры и постепенные меры

Как вариант.
На «героические меры» Яндекс много чего выдает.
Note from asker:
Поздравляю Вас с праздником, Лена! Большое спасибо за участие в обсуждении и интересный вариант.
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search