Glossary entry

Turkish term or phrase:

ihsasi rey

English translation:

comments reflecting bias

Added to glossary by Harold Lemel
Oct 27, 2008 00:47
15 yrs ago
4 viewers *
Turkish term

ihsasi rey

Turkish to English Law/Patents Law (general)
Would this be "pre-judged" or "biased"?

Discussion

chevirmen Oct 27, 2008:
Kanaat Davayla ilgili bir kanaat veya hüküm teşkili esas olduğunda, zımnen yapılması ihsas-ı reyi teşkil eder. Dava esnasında açık olması, tarafgirlik olur, bu da davayla ilgili taraflara redd-i hakim hakkı tanır.
Nuri Razi Oct 27, 2008:
ihsası rey ihsas: TDK'ya göre üstü kapalı anlatma, sezdirme, ima
ihsas etmek: sezdirmek, ima etmek
rey: oy, düşüncü fikir
ihsası rey: görüşünü üstü örtülü ifade etmek, dolaylı demeçlerden
skaya Oct 27, 2008:
gizli veya açık farketmez üstü kapalı olması gibi bir şart olduğunu sanmıyorum. örneğin, özelleştirme ile ilgili bir davaya bakacak bir hakimin önceden özelleştirme karşıtı açıklamaları olması ihsas-ı reydir.
gulakbelen (X) Oct 27, 2008:
üstü kapalı ifade/beyan

bir yargıcın sürmekte olan ve bakmakla yükümlü olduğu bir dava ile ilgili görüşünü beyan etmesi.

Proposed translations

13 hrs
Selected

comments reflecting bias

Prof. Dr. Ejder YILMAZ'ın "HUKUK SÖZLÜĞÜ" ne göre:

ihsası rey - Kanaat belirtilmesı; görüşün hissettirilmesi; bir kimsenin (kendi) düşüncesini belli etmesi; yargılamada yargıç, ihsası reyde bulunursa bu bir red (hakiminin reddedilmesi) nedenidir.

Bence aşağıdaki resmi metinde "comments reflecting bias" ibaresi bu anlamına kullanıldı:

http://74.125.39.104/search?q=cache:Qz1oDOMGTCIJ:jtc.courts....
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks. Yes, something like an indication that the judge has pr-judged the issue; that he was applying subjectivity or bias. I am not sure if "insuate an opinion" as another person suggested captures this, exactly. In the text, one of the lawyers is complaining that the legal opinion on "ihsasi rey" may be invoked, which based on what others said, might disqualify the judge from deciding the issue. "
+2
8 hrs

insinuate an opinion

ihsası rey: ‘İhsası rey’ şudur. (hakimlerin) Bakılmakta olan veya bakması olası bir davada oyunu ihsas ettirme yani sezindirme, yani ima yoluyla açıklama demek.”, bu en geçerli tarif Sabih Kanadoğlu’na aittir.
ihsas etmek: insinuate
http://www.tureng.com/search/ihsas etmek
"[i]t is not claimed-nor can it be-that this judge ever uttered or even INSINUATED ANY OPINION about [petitioner], the merits of his case, or his guilt or innocence."
www.usdoj.gov/osg/briefs/2003/0responses/2003-0575.resp.htm... - 27k

"He is expected to go back into court under a "Rule 35" and the judge insinuated that he would reduce his 70 month sentence then"
www.prisontalk.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-57019.html - 17k

ayrıca bakabilirsiniz :
http://www.google.com.tr/search?q="insinuate an opinion" jud...


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 9 hrs (2008-10-27 09:56:38 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

ihsası rey: implicitly expressing opinion on a lawsuit (By Sabih Kanadoğlu, Chief Presecutor)
Example sentence:

""[i]t is not claimed-nor can it be-that this judge ever uttered or even INSINUATED ANY OPINION about [petitioner], the merits of his case, or his guilt or innocence"

Peer comment(s):

agree chevirmen : To imply or to express implicitly the opinion or judgment for an on-going case or possible case. reference:Sabih Kanadoğlu, Honorary Republican Chief Prosecutor
4 hrs
Teşekkür ederim.
agree semen
6 hrs
Teşekkür ederim.
Something went wrong...
15 hrs

inexplicit expression

Üstü kapalı ifade anlamında kullanılmış.
Something went wrong...
6 hrs

rejection of the judge

when there is a doubt concerning the objective decision of the judge you can reject that judge to decide for that court case. this is called ''ihsasi rey''

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 15 saat (2008-10-27 15:59:20 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

hakimlerin karardan once fikir/kanaat belirtmesi ''ihsasi rey''dir ve bu mahkemenin objektifligi konusunda soru isareti ve bu reddi hakim nedenidir ama reddi hakim ve ihsasi rey ayni degil. ama ben rejcetion of the judge diye sacmalarsam elbette sonuc bu olur.
ozur dilerim. ingilizcesi bu durmda insuniation of the opinion oluyor.
Peer comment(s):

neutral chevirmen : redd-i hakim...
6 hrs
Something went wrong...
18 hrs

expression of opinion

Judicial disqualification

.....

28 U.S.C. sec. 144, captioned ** "Bias or prejudice of judge," ** provides that under circumstances, when a party to a case in a United States District Court files a "timely and sufficient affidavit that the judge before whom the matter is pending has a personal bias or prejudice either against him or in favor of an adverse party," the case shall be transferred to another judge.

The general rule is that to warrant recusal, a judge's ** expression of an opinion ** about the merits of a case or familiarity with the facts or the parties must have originated in a source outside the case itself. This is referred to in the United States as the "extra-judicial source rule" and was recognized as a general presumption, although not an invariable one, in the 1994 U.S. Supreme Court decision in Liteky v. United States.

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 18 hrs (2008-10-27 19:03:24 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

expression of opinion (outside the case)
Something went wrong...
63 days

implication

self-explatory
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search