Apr 25, 2008 22:48
16 yrs ago
Spanish term

Por favor leer explicacion

Spanish to English Art/Literary Poetry & Literature La Naturaleza en Ingles
I'm translating a fiction novel (not for children) (Spanish-English). In many parts of the story, I come across with phrases such as ' ...mientras el sol se preparaba para ser acunado en el fondo de rio' or 'la luna alcahuetera escuchaba atentamente...' As far as I understand, I cannot really have the moon/sun performing human actions in English. Does anyone have an opinion about this? I tried to get access to the forum but couldn't. Thanks

Discussion

Lynda Tharratt Apr 28, 2008:
Carolyn, I think that by changing these actions you would be doing a great injustice to the author. How about "as the sun snuggled into the river bed to be rocked to sleep"?
Carolyn Dorrell (asker) Apr 28, 2008:
Hope this helps Sure Clayton. The first sentence for instance Catalina seemed to remember that it must have been sometime around the end of the summer when Master Ambrosio came to the bank as the sun was about to set into the river as, the first concerto of toads could be heard and the herons, mbiguas and king-fishers had all gone to sleep. (That is how I translated it) It didn't sound right to translate it as: Master Ambrosio came to the bank as the sun was getting ready to be rocked in the craddle of the river... (or something similar...)
Clayton Causey Apr 27, 2008:
Can we have a full-sentence context (or possibly several) so we can make sure we're addressing your concern?

Proposed translations

2 days 17 hrs
Selected

Yes, but with quite a bit of retooling, here's an option

"Catalina seemed to remember that Master Ambrosio must have come to the riverside sometime around the end of the summer when the tired sun was falling into the river’s watery bed, when the toads were performing their first annual concerto, after the herons, mbiguas(?), and king-fishers had all gone to sleep."

(If he really did come to a financial institution I recommend replacing riverside with bank. Otherwise, bank seems too ambiguous to me.)
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Thanks a lot to you all!"
+18
11 mins

of course they can

Looking for more examples from adult stories:

Stories of the Moon Clan-- An Amazon TribeThe moon listened and watched and waited. The moon stared down in cool splendor at the madness, pleased by it all. The goddess' face was inscrutable as she ...
www.icubed.com/~ljg/moonclan_08.html - 41k - Cached - Similar pages

My BlogAs the moon listened to the words left unsaid. January 10, 2008 | Permalink | Comments (0). tula ni dumlao na nagpatulo ng baldeng luha isang gabing ...
bolpenatpapel.blogs.friendster.com/my_blog/ - 18k - Cached - Similar pages

Never index your own book.: The moon listens carefully to little boys.Kevin screamed something indecipherable at it a few times while jumping a little, and then, after the last time, said “Hey, the moon listened to me that ...
bugsbeetlesbootsbrail.blogspot.com/2006/03/moon-listens-carefully-to-little-boys.html - 22k - Cached - Similar pages

Xinggan's Naivete'With salt-tasted drops streaming down my cheeks, I divulged the only thing that has been kept so long inside me. But only the moon listened. ...
renah_14.blogs.friendster.com/wenski/ - 61k - Cached - Similar pages


--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 20 mins (2008-04-25 23:09:27 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

I forgot to add above that this is called "personification". Here is an explanation;
PERSONIFICATION


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Personification is giving human qualities to animals or objects.

Example:
a smiling moon, a jovial sun

In "Mirror" by Sylvia Plath, for example, the mirror--the "I" in the first line--is given the ability to speak, see and swallow, as well as human attributes such as truthfulness.

I am silver and exact.
I have no preconceptions.
Whatever I see I swallow immediately
Just as it is, unmisted by love or dislike.
I am not cruel, only truthful--

In John Keats' "To Autumn," the fall season is personified as "sitting careless on a granary floor" (line 14) and "drowsed with the fume of poppies" (line 17.)
See Anthropomorphism for more.

Peer comment(s):

agree Jennifer Levey : Yes, almost anything can be personified in English (even my mother-in-law!).
3 mins
lm*o, thanks!
agree Marian Martin (X) : Examples on the internet are not hard to find. http://vintagechildrensbooksmykidloves.blogspot.com/2008/03/...
8 mins
thanks!
agree RichardDeegan : Also common in the trashy novels I read :-)
12 mins
of course, eh-hem, so I've heard...:)
agree Nelida Kreer : The towering cliffs, the menacing forest, the welcoming lake, etc. ad infinitum. Nice work.
24 mins
thanks Niki!
agree Ximena P. Aguilar : of course! it's also part of the figurative language, it adds interest to the literature...
24 mins
...and (I might add) is an important feature of the magical realism genre of Latin American literature...thanks Ximena!
agree Marcelo Gonçalves
24 mins
thanks Marcelo!
agree margaret caulfield
55 mins
thanks Margaret!
agree Margarita Gonzalez : Indeed, and as Mediamatrix says, even the unthinkable!
4 hrs
thanks MargaEsther!
agree Patrice
5 hrs
thanks Patrice!
agree Carol Gullidge : definitely (although this should perhaps have been posted in English-English...? Or perhaps that's what Carolyn meant by "the forum")
8 hrs
thanks Carol!
agree Bubo Coroman (X) : very nice references
9 hrs
thanks Deborah!
agree Gary Smith Lawson : I find metaphors used more frequently in spoken Spanish than in English, but there's an infinity of examples in English literature. Shakespeare being but one.
10 hrs
thanks Gary!
agree Egmont
11 hrs
thanks AVRVM!
agree Victoria Porter-Burns : definitely
16 hrs
thanks Victoria!
agree jude dabo : ok
17 hrs
thanks jude!
agree Sandra Rodriguez : YES, THEY CAN!!!
17 hrs
thanks Sandra!
agree Gert Sass (M.A.)
4 days
thanks Gert!
agree Abraal
7 days
thanks Rain!
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search