https://www.proz.com/kudoz/finnish-to-english/science-general/2117233-kaikesta-syrj%C3%A4ytynyt-ihminen.html

Glossary entry

Finnish term or phrase:

syrjäytynyt jostakin

English translation:

marginalised from

Added to glossary by Alfa Trans (X)
Sep 2, 2007 07:52
16 yrs ago
Finnish term

kaikesta syrjäytynyt ihminen

Finnish to English Other Science (general) education
Esim vankilassa olo voi johtaa siihen, että ihminen syrjäytyy kaikesta.
Proposed translations (English)
4 +1 a (totally) marginalised person
4 -1 someone who is withdrawn from everything

Discussion

Alfa Trans (X) (asker) Sep 4, 2007:
Kudoz is better than a dictionary I think the rest of the world is to blame if someone becomes marginalised, don't you? Excluded is definitely also a good suggestion in this context.

Withdrawn suggests that you are shy and cause the situation yourself.

Thank you everybody, I find this most interesting. These are things you don't find in a dictionary, as the ideas are too new. It will take years for them to be included in a dictionary, with examples.
Alfa Trans (X) (asker) Sep 2, 2007:
En tarkoita KAIKEsta, vaan kaikeSTA eli prepositiota äimistelen. Joskus on vaikeaa jopa asettaa se oikea kysymys, kun itse ajaa jotain karannutta ajatusta takaa...

Onko se todella esimerkiksi marginalised from social life. Hyvä, sitä tarkoitin.
Alfa Trans (X) (asker) Sep 2, 2007:
KAIKESTA syrjäytynyt on se tärkein kysymys, esim kaikesta seurustelusta, ilonpidosta jne. Mikä prepositio sopii parhaiten. Totally ei käy tähän, vaikka se tietysti on sinänsä oikein.

Proposed translations

+1
17 mins
Selected

a (totally) marginalised person

linkki aika hyvään psykon sanastoon alla, tosin ei sisällä syrjäytymistä

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 hr (2007-09-02 09:05:45 GMT)
--------------------------------------------------

marginalised from all social activities/society etc. Marginalised from everything on IMHO liian epämääräinen, suomeksi myös; ei kukaan voi olla KAIKESTA syrjäytynyt ellei ole ihan erakko.
Peer comment(s):

agree Spencer Allman
1 hr
Something went wrong...
4 KudoZ points awarded for this answer. Comment: "Tämä hyvä."
-1
5 hrs

someone who is withdrawn from everything

The "marginalised/marginalized" answers lay the blame at the door of the rest of the world, whereas "syrjäytynyt" is really reflexive. Especially in the context of the other questions today--school--I would talk about someone being withdrawn and shy, not marginalized (although that definition is better in the political-social way this word is often used in Finland).

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 1 day8 hrs (2007-09-03 16:08:45 GMT) Post-grading
--------------------------------------------------

I don't disagree with the previous definitions, but I do think there is an interesting linguistic and cultural difference here. This idea of social exclusion is really big in Europe (syrjäytynyt is a surprisingly common term in Finnish political discourse), but very much less so in the US. I think here we still tend to assign more responsibility to the individual than to keep themselves engaged, which of course is problematic in many situations. Here's another term I like: "the dispossessed".

--------------------------------------------------
Note added at 2 days4 hrs (2007-09-04 12:36:38 GMT) Post-grading
--------------------------------------------------

Well, that's really my point. In the US, we generally fundamentally reject the notion that individuals are not responsible for their own welfare. This is why the true welfare state has not developed here. Right or wrong, the generally view is that when people are excluded, it is generally their own fault. The opposing view, more common in Europe, and here represented broadly by the Liberal/Democratic approach, has an amazing ability to lose easy elections.
Peer comment(s):

disagree Spencer Allman : syrjaytynyt can also mean 'excluded'. It is a subtle point but please see http://eur-lex.europa.eu/Notice.do?mode=dbl&lng1=fi,en&lang=...
1 day 7 mins
Something went wrong...